By Book or Bagel

The challenge of preserving Jewish culture in an intermarriage is to emphasize the content and not just the trappings of Judaism.

By Laurel Snyder

Intermarriage is either the biggest hurdle the Jewish community has ever faced, or the biggest scapegoat.

Don’t get me wrong, the recent and overwhelming trend in Jewish intermarriage is complicated, but when people talk about intermarriage, they often seem to suggest that intermarriage is at the root of Jewish assimilation, that people are marrying and then losing their ties to the tradition, when the reverse might be closer to the truth.

Because in a world of “Just Jews” who say things like, “You don’t have to believe in God to be Jewish,” does it really matter who Davey Feinstein takes to the Chuppah? What’s he got to pass on to his children anyway?

I don’t mean to suggest that there aren’t meaningful ways to be Jewish beyond traditional religious observance and devotion, but when I was working on college campuses for Hillel, promoting a renaissance in Jewish campus life, I was amazed that most students didn’t identify with the content of Judaism so much as they identified with the appearance of Jewish culture.

Not only weren’t they kosher; they also weren’t socialists or Zionists, and they didn’t read Singer or Potak. They seemed disinterested in Jewish art, history, geography, and mysticism, but they could list off all the Jewish celebrities, and they liked bagels. That was important—they knew a good bagel when they ate one.

Recently I was talking with “Yael,” an Israeli friend of mine. Yael and her husband are Jewish, though neither of them grew up attending synagogue or Hebrew school, but Yael explained to me that she’s looking to join a synagogue, and that she wants to enroll her son in Jewish Day School.

“Why?” I asked.

“Well, my whole sense of what it means to be Jewish is based on being Israeli,” she explained, “but my kids are American. Being a secular Jewish Israeli in America feels like it has meaning, and it offers community… but what does a secular Jewish American have to pass on? Why is that a religion?”

Which got me thinking—that because she could see a huge shift within one generation, Yael was able to identify what so many American Jews can’t perceive. We all stand at a distance from observant Jewish tradition on one side, and complete assimilation on the other, and so we forget just how far we are from each. We just hope that our kids will lead lives a little like our own. Most of us forget that our grandparents came to this country keeping kosher and arguing Talmud, and that our parents, while not quite so observant, attended synagogue weekly as kids, and lived by the Jewish calendar. But what is a Gen X Jew? Most of us don’t keep kosher, wake up on Saturdays for synagogue, read Jewish books, or otherwise participate in the community, but we want to claim our culture.

Which is where, perhaps, this intense fear of intermarriage comes from, this fear that our brisket recipes and Yiddishism might get lost in the watered-down bloodlines of the American melting pot. This fear that our children will intermarry and lose what little birthright we have left to hand down. But is that the fault of intermarriage or a lackluster birthright?

I am doing all I can to preserve the Jewish culture. I am learning, praying, writing Jewish books, cooking Jewish foods, respecting the tradition in an intentional manner. And I will take all the energy I could spend fearing intermarriage, and harness it, to teach my son to read and learn and think and grow as a Jew. Because if it happens that my mother is not Jewish, and my husband is not Jewish, then it is my job to assure that my son will be Jewish—a man of the book, not the bagel.

If you’d like to comment on this article, click here.

Add to Del.icio.us   Digg This   Fave on Technorati

Laurel Snyder is the editor of Half/Life: Jewish Tales from Interfaith Homes (Soft Skull Press, 2006), and a blogger (JewishyIrishy.com).

Back to top

October 4, 2008

Palin Watch IV: Post-Debate Musings
By Mary Beth Crain
This hockey mom belongs in the penalty box.

September 25, 2008

Palin Watch III: Dumb and Getting Dumber
By Mary Beth Crain
As she faced the formidable Katie Couric in her second big time interview, Sarah Palin was palin'.

September 23, 2008

Holy Crap
By Billy Frolick
Joe Eszterhas turns his rapture into a purpose-driven pitch.

September 20, 2008

Palin Watch, II: Secrets and Lies
By Mary Beth Crain
In the Sarah Palin Archives of Deception, "Troopergate" is front and center.

September 14, 2008

Palin Watch, I
By Mary Beth Crain
Have we really turned the country over to C students?

September 5, 2008

Backward, Christian Soldiers
By Mary Beth Crain
The Republicans are touting Sarah Palin as the new symbol of change. They're right--she's busy changing the clock back, way back.

August 22, 2008

A Sheep in Sheep's Clothing?
By John Fea
Eight years ago, John McCain locked horns with the Christian Right. Now he's one of them?

July 11, 2008

Jesse Jackson's Gaffe: Oh, Those Annoying Men of God
By Mary Beth Crain
Bothersome preachers have been a highlight of the 2008 presidential campaign. Where are these bigoted egomaniacs coming from, and how can they be stopped?

July 9, 2008

Just Married
By Stephanie Hunt
After 20 years of marriage, our author ponders the meaning of "I do."

June 23, 2008

Confessions of a Serial Killer's Mother
By Mary Beth Crain
In the midst of spring's grace and summer's radiance, God shows his cruel side.

April 28, 2008

The Rev. Wright Stuff
By Mary Beth Crain
Today's prophets aren't any more popular than they were in the time of another Jeremiah.

April 18, 2008

Why I Want to Be Pope
By Mary Beth Crain
The Holy Father has a private jet, a cadre of valets, and a pipeline to God. Wouldn't you want to be him?

April 15, 2008

Entering the Kingdom of Kitsch
By Timothy Beal
Daniel Radosh's excellent adventure in the quirky world of Christian pop culture.

April 11, 2008

Missionary Reposition
By Stephanie Hunt
For our writer, the challenges of a Honduran mission trip began before touchdown.

March 13, 2008

High School Reunion Blues
By Mary Beth Crain
Wondering whether or not to go to your reunion? Take a tip from the Buddha--and stay home.